Remodeling vs. New Construction – Is There a Difference?

Can a residential contractor manage both remodeling projects and new construction projects successfully? Well that depend. On the surface, remodeling and new construction appear to be similar. But are they? Sure, they both incorporate similar materials & products and upon completion the may even appears to be identical.  However, there are inherent differences between each project type; some obvious and some not-so-obvious. Our firm provides architectural services for remodeling projects as well as new construction. Over the past decade, we have observed the unique differences between the two project types.

While a new home is typically constructed in a methodical sequence from commencement to completion, a home renovation often involves many intricate steps that need to be coordinated with clock-like precision. Selective or partial demolition is a common component of a home renovation. Frequently load-bearing walls are removed and structural members are modified. The existing construction needs to be  properly supported until the new framing elements are in place. In response to the desire for an open-plan, it is customary to reroute and reconfigure mechanical, plumbing and electrical systems whence interior walls are removed.

The construction schedule for a renovation project is often impacted by the fact that the homeowner is living in the house during the project. Items such as start & end times of the workday will need to respond to the homeowner’s schedule. There may be “black-out” days on the schedule that are caused by life-events. The work schedule should be clearly reviewed with the homeowner prior to commencement.  Moreover, the contractor and sub-contractors need to be aware of their behavior on the job-site. The significance of a smoke-free job-site with acceptable language and appropriate music cannot be over emphasized.

A fundamental goal of renovation projects is to complement the existing character of the home. An addition should not look like it is an addition. The new work should be woven into the fabric of the existing construction. It is also important to consider the personality of the neighborhood. The materials for the project should be selected to create a coherent design solution. A remodeling project will regularly require the need to accurately replicate details and profiles.

Large renovation projects are often divided into smaller, manageable phases. A master-plan will illustrate the overall project in its entirety. The intent of a master-plan is for each phase of the project to be “self-sufficient” and not dependent upon the later phases to be considered complete. It is common for the architect, remodeler and homeowner to work together to create a master-plan for the project.

Like most relationships, success comes from good communication and teamwork. -jfa

And the CotY Goes to: JFA Architecture!

JFA Architecture, along with Gemmi Construction Inc, has been honored with a Contractor of the Year (CotY) Award by the Bucks-Mont Chapter of the National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI.) Their work on an entire home remodeling project in the $250,000–500,000 category stood out from the competition, earning them the coveted 2010 CotY Award.

The award winning work by JFA Architecture and Gemmi Construction was performed on behalf of the Scott family of Maple Glen, Pennsylvania. The Scott’s have lived in their 1960′s era home for more than 20 years, raising 5 children there.

Both Greg and Sally come from large families and regularly host family gatherings with 30 or more people in attendance. With their children grown–three of five having left the nest–the Scott’s felt it was the right time to make a few changes around the house. Having a large extended family, the Scott’s wanted better space for entertaining big groups. Plus, they wanted to update their dated master bedroom and bath, finish their basement and add a few features they had always wanted, like a mud room and home office. Aware that it lacked curb appeal, they also wanted to give their home an exterior face lift.

With their wish list of improvements and budget set, they approached Bucks-Mont NARI members Joseph Augustine of JFA Architecture and John Gemmi, of Gemmi Construction for a proposal on their project. Fewer than 12 months later the Scott’s were living in the home of their dreams, complete with a finished basement, great room, mud room, home office, spacious master bedroom suite, renovated exterior with new siding and windows, a renovated garage and more.

In designing this project, Augustine was careful to incorporate the features the Scott’s desired in a harmonious manner, with great consideration given to the functionality and transition between rooms. He was also successful in balancing Sally and Greg’s desire for a craftsman style home with the realities of their budget. “Joe really got our vision,” commented Sally Scott. “The details Joe included in the design made all the difference.”

Augustine teamed with Gemmi Construction to bring the design to life for his clients. “I enjoyed working with John Gemmi and his team on the Scott’s home. It was a great collaborative effort.” Clearly, the Scott family and the CotY judges agreed.

House & Home Magazine – Montgomery County – May 2009

“A New Beginning for a Beloved Home

…Ends with an Award-Winning Outcome”

2009 TRIPLE AWARD WINNING PROJECT

NARI – Contractor of the Year Regional Winner – “Entire House Renovation”

HBA – Pinnacle Award Winner – “Best Residential Renovation”

Dream Home Award – “Best Whole House Remodel”

  Click this link to read the article!